导航|地址|刷新
FIM appeal reports | Department of Fores…

Skip to main content

Search

FISHERIES MANAGEMENT

DFFE Main

FIM home

Management

Projects & Programmes
Fishing rights allocation process (FRAP)

FRAP 2020/21 SEIAS

Small scale fisheries (SSF)

Operation Phakisa

Documents
Annual reports + APP + Strategic Plans

Research reports and projects

Strategy and framework

Publications | awareness material

Legislation
Public notices
FRAP

Miscellaneous

Appeals
General published reasons (GPR)

Reports

Permits
About marine and freshwater aquaculture

Applying for marine aquaculture rights and permits

Applying for freshwater aquaculture permits

Applying for import and export permits

Forms and templates

e-Permitting: fishing permit system

Permit conditions

Careers
Skills development programme

Oceans and coasts

Events
International + awareness days

Protected areas

EGIS - maps

Main navigation

Home

About
Ministry
Minister D Maynier

Deputy Minister B Swarts

Deputy Minister N Singh

Overview of the department - DG

Structure of the department

Entities

Provincial Departments of Environment

Webmaster contacts

Branches
Biodiversity and Conservation

Chemicals and Waste Management

Climate Change and Air Quality

Corporate Management Services

Environmental Programmes

Financial Management Services

Fisheries Management

Forestry Management

Regulatory Compliance and Sector Monitoring

Oceans and Coasts

Tenders

Careers
Bursaries

Internships

Green careers

Vacancies

Legislation
Bills

Green papers

White papers

Acts and regulations

International agreements and obligations

Gazetted notices

Appeals
DFFE

Fisheries GPR

Fisheries appeal reports

Public notices
DFFE

Fisheries - all

FRAP

Documents
Annual reports + APP + Strategic Plans
DFFE

MLRF

Supply chain management

Strategy and framework

Forms

e-Tools
State of the environment report (SOER)

e-Permitting Fishing Permit System

Environmental Geographic Information Systems (EGIS)

Resources

Media
Media Releases

PARLIAMENTARY Q&A

Media contacts

Speeches

Publications

G20 - ECSWG

Contact

Breadcrumb

Home .

FIM appeal reports

FIM appeal reports

Submitted by mtladi on September 30, 2025

APPEAL REPORTS - FISHERIES ALL

Fisheries appeal reports are formal documents that detail and justify decisions made by the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment in response to appeals against decisions related to the allocation of commercial fishing rights. These reports provide reasons and legal basis for upholding or overturning earlier decisions, outlining the minister's considerations of fairness, transformation, and the sustainability of the fishing sector, and can include analyses of applicants' scores, performance, and adherence to policies. The individual appeal decisions provide specific reasons for each case while the general published reasons (GPRs) document the overall approach to appeals in a specific sector.

NON EXCLUSIONS

EXCLUSIONS

ENVIRONMENTAL AUTHORISATIONS

non exclusions

2018 west coast rock lobster sector

all files are .pdf, unless otherwise stated.

zone b

WCNF150327: Andrew Petrus Johannes De Klerk [305 kb]

WCND151096: Cecil Mzamo Mvayi [630.17 kb]

WCNF150716: Chadwick Joel Gillion [339 kb]

WCND150112: Deborah Magdalena Mary Thebus [537 kb]

WCNB15178: Deidre Elvona van Wyk [708.15 kb]

WCNF150982: Desmond Clemont Brian Makka [860.83 kb]

WCNB15625: Desmond Pedro Adams [766.52 kb]

WCND151252: Donovan Du Preez [94.35 kb]

WCNF152332: Dorethea Sarie November [593.49 kb]

WCND151098: Elcot Dyantyi [521.11 kb]

WCNB15209: Estelle Rachel Heyns [729. 92 kb]

WCNF150545: Gail Cornelius [309.74 kb]

WCNF151629: Gavin Harold Pietersen [3374. 19 kb]

WCNB15572: Gert Saulus Simon [670. 27 kb]

WCNF152492: Gregory Pretorius [362.11 kb]

WCNB15209: Heidi lillian Pietersen [1.24 MB]

WCND150646: Hendrik Boois [520.73 kb]

WCND150214: Jabian Arries [516.85 kb]

WCND151185: James Hendricks [679.64 kb]

WCNB151016: Jan Willem Dirks [676.55 kb]

WCNF151336: Jerome Curbon Figaji [318.13 kb]

WCND150916: Kevin Woodward [738.98 kb]

zone c

WCNE150682: Jaliel Keyser [799.78 kb]

zone e

WCNE150668: Galiema Baderoen [659.18 kb]

WCNE150601: Johannes Lakey [710.11 kb]

WCNE150615: Spinach John Nkunzana [1.03 mb]

WCNE150309: Deon Bester [323.54 kb]

nearshore

WCNA15314: lsmael Hermanus Saal [794.01 kb]

WCNB15573: Calvin Moses Van der Heever [770.32 kb]

offshore

WCOM152163: Dromedaris Vissery Ltd [135.66 kb]

WCNB15209: lnkosi Keta Marine (Pty) Ltd CC [1.51 MB]

WCOM153484: Karbonkelberg Marine CC [2.08 MB]

WCOM153510: Konsortium Kreefbelange (Pty) Ltd [2.38 MB]

WCOM153480: Bubesi Fishing (Pty) LTD [2 mb]

WCOM153482: Cape Reef Products (Pty) LTD [2.17 mb]

miscellaneous

WCNA15439: Jacqueline Leggett [554.69 kb]

2015 demersal shark sector

DMS130145: G&K Fisheries CC [877 kb]

DMS 130147: Dragon Fish Fisherman CC [383.16 kb]

DMS 130184: JNC Fishing (Pty) LTD [359.59 kb]

DMS 130185: Hacky Fishing (Pty) LTD [996.44 kb]

DMS 130219: Cape Town Harbour Fisherman's Community Trust [486.4 kb]

DMS 130228: Overberg Commercial Abalone Divers LTD [473.88 kb]

DMS 130243: Villet Dewet 100 CC [366.42 kb]

DMS 130322: Khoi Groep 13 Services Co-operative [496 kb]

DMS 130349: Yellow Star Trading 1154 (Pty) LTD [405 kb]

DMS 130359: BEVCON General Trading (Pty) LTD [368.69 kb]

DMS 130360: New Horizon Primary Fishing [435.47 kb]

DMS 130457: GOAPRO (Pty) LTD [365.59 kb]

DMS 130569: Ulwandle Fishing (Pty) LTD [829.17 kb]

DMS 130574: Mbotho Fishing [380.08 kb]

DMS 130590: FINECORP Trading 113 (Pty) LTD [274.9 kb]

DMS 130605: Ubuhle Bezwe Holdings (Pty) LTD [380.82 kb]

DMS 130737: Collin Govender [417.05 kb]

DMS 130806: Tshatshu Seafood Industry [400.07 kb]

DMS 130809: Mnyama Women Commerical Fishing Enterprise (Pty) LTD [389.09 kb]

DMS 130901: Coalition Trading 672 CC [383.87

DMS 130916: Trade Factor 16 (Pty) LTD [424.14 kb]

2015 white mussels sector

Appellants domiciled within the City of Cape Town: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [288.09 kb]

Appellants domiciled outside the jurisdiction of the west coast and the City of Cape Town: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [401.79]

Appellants domiciled along the west coast harvesting zones 2,3,4,5,6, and 7: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [413.09 kb]

exclusions

2018 west coast rock lobster sector

all files are .pdf, unless otherwise stated.

zone a

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [185 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [185 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [293 kb]

zone b

Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [181 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [213 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [651 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [861 kb]

West coast rock lobster zone B appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [261 kb]

zone c

Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [178 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [238 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [317 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [434 kb]

West coast rock lobster zone C appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [177 kb]

zone d

West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [191 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [2 716 kb]

West coast rock lobster zone D appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [174 kb]

zone e

Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [186 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [186 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category E and C new entrants to become successful applicants [395 kb]

zone f

Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [565 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [2 278 kb]

Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [1 822 kb]

zone g

WCNF150023 Zukiswa Ellen Mqhokrwana: accessibility of suitable fishing vessel and fishing performance grounds of appeal [387 kb]

nearshore

WCNB15472 Wilfred James Dampies: fishing performance and transformation [123 kb]

offshore

Appeals excluded for being co-operatives [143.83 kb]

Paper quota risk applicants [210.94 kb]

Failure to sign / commission the application forms [185.04 kb]

Submitting materially defective applications in that they provided false information [132.35 kb]

Non-disclosure of MLRA violations [253.35 kb]

Category A applicants for scoring below 60% threshold [265.02 kb]

Category B applicants as the category is not allowed in the west coast rock lobster offshore fishery [265 kb]

Category C applicants for scoring below 50% threshold [502.60 kb]

environmental authorisations (ea)

2021 sea-based aquaculture development zone (adz)

all files are .pdf, unless otherwise stated.

18 June 2021

Appeals lodged against environmental authorisation in terms of the National Environmental Management Act, Act No. 107 Of 1998, as amended: The establishment of sea-based aquaculture development zone (ADZ) in Algoa Bay, within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality, Eastern Cape Province. [5.4 mb]

26 February 2021

Application for environmental authorisation in terms of the National Environmental Management Act, Act No. 107 Of 1998, as amended: The establishment of sea-based aquaculture development zone (ADZ) in Algoa Bay, within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality, Eastern Cape Province. [6.36 mb]

We as humanity continue to consume the earths' resources at ever increasing and unsustainable rates.

CONTACT US

OPERATING HOURS
Monday - Friday: 08:00 - 16:30
Weekends and public holidays: closed.

SWITCH BOARD
Tel: +27 12 399 9000| Fax:+27 12 359 3625

DFFE CALL CENTRE
+27 86 111 2468|callcentre@dffe.gov.za

ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES HOTLINE
0800 205 005|envirocrime@dffe.gov.za

FISHERIES / FRAP RELATED ENQUIRIES
+27 66 471 0748|+27 82 782 8299|cscenquiries@dffe.gov.za

RECREATIONAL FISHING ENQUIRIES
+27 66 471 0748|+27 82 782 8299|epenquiries@dffe.gov.za

Explore

About the website

Terms of use

Sitemap

Links

PAIA and POPIA

EDMS

Outlook

ADDRESSES

PRETORIA OFFICE
Environment House,
Cnr. Steve Biko (previously Beatrix Street) and Soutpansberg Road,
473 Steve Biko,
Arcadia,
Pretoria, 0083
South Africa

POSTAL ADDRESS
Private Bag X447
…(内容过长已截断)

------
导航页打开网址


zone b
	WCNF150327: Andrew Petrus Johannes De Klerk [305 kb]
WCND151096: Cecil Mzamo Mvayi [630.17 kb]
WCNF150716: Chadwick Joel Gillion [339 kb]
WCND150112: Deborah Magdalena Mary Thebus [537 kb]
WCNB15178: Deidre Elvona van Wyk [708.15 kb]
WCNF150982: Desmond Clemont Brian Makka [860.83 kb]
WCNB15625: Desmond Pedro Adams [766.52 kb]
WCND151252: Donovan Du Preez [94.35 kb]
WCNF152332: Dorethea Sarie November [593.49 kb]
WCND151098: Elcot Dyantyi [521.11 kb]
WCNB15209: Estelle Rachel Heyns [729. 92 kb]
WCNF150545: Gail Cornelius [309.74 kb]
WCNF151629: Gavin Harold Pietersen [3374. 19 kb]
WCNB15572: Gert Saulus Simon [670. 27 kb]
WCNF152492: Gregory Pretorius [362.11 kb]
WCNB15209: Heidi lillian Pietersen [1.24 MB]
WCND150646: Hendrik Boois [520.73 kb]
WCND150214: Jabian Arries [516.85 kb]
WCND151185: James Hendricks [679.64 kb]
WCNB151016: Jan Willem Dirks [676.55 kb]
WCNF151336: Jerome Curbon Figaji [318.13 kb]
WCND150916: Kevin Woodward [738.98 kb]
zone c
	WCNE150682: Jaliel Keyser [799.78 kb]
zone e
	WCNE150668: Galiema Baderoen [659.18 kb]
WCNE150601: Johannes Lakey [710.11 kb]
WCNE150615: Spinach John Nkunzana [1.03 mb]
WCNE150309: Deon Bester [323.54 kb]
nearshore
	WCNA15314: lsmael Hermanus Saal [794.01 kb]
WCNB15573: Calvin Moses Van der Heever [770.32 kb]
offshore
	WCOM152163: Dromedaris Vissery Ltd [135.66 kb]
WCNB15209: lnkosi Keta Marine (Pty) Ltd CC [1.51 MB]
WCOM153484: Karbonkelberg Marine CC [2.08 MB]
WCOM153510: Konsortium Kreefbelange (Pty) Ltd [2.38 MB]
WCOM153480: Bubesi Fishing (Pty) LTD [2 mb]
WCOM153482: Cape Reef Products (Pty) LTD [2.17 mb]
miscellaneous
	WCNA15439: Jacqueline Leggett [554.69 kb]


zone a
	Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [185 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [185 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [293 kb]
zone b
	Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [181 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [213 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [651 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [861 kb]
West coast rock lobster zone B appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [261 kb]
zone c
	Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [178 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [238 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants who are medically unfit to become successful applicants [317 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [434 kb]
West coast rock lobster zone C appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [177 kb]
zone d
	West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [191 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [2 716 kb]
West coast rock lobster zone D appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [174 kb]
zone e
	Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [186 kb]
	Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [186 kb]
	Delegated authority's decision not to allow category E and C new entrants to become successful applicants [395 kb]
zone f
	Appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [565 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [2 278 kb]
Delegated authority's decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [1 822 kb]
zone g
	WCNF150023 Zukiswa Ellen Mqhokrwana: accessibility of suitable fishing vessel and fishing performance grounds of appeal [387 kb]
nearshore
	WCNB15472 Wilfred James Dampies: fishing performance and transformation [123 kb]
offshore
	Appeals excluded for being co-operatives [143.83 kb]
Paper quota risk applicants [210.94 kb]
Failure to sign / commission the application forms [185.04 kb]
Submitting materially defective applications in that they provided false information [132.35 kb]
Non-disclosure of MLRA violations [253.35 kb]
Category A applicants for scoring below 60% threshold [265.02 kb]
Category B applicants as the category is not allowed in the west coast rock lobster offshore fishery [265 kb]
Category C applicants for scoring below 50% threshold [502.60 kb]


18 June 2021	Appeals lodged against environmental authorisation in terms of the National Environmental Management Act, Act No. 107 Of 1998, as amended: The establishment of sea-based aquaculture development zone (ADZ) in Algoa Bay, within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality, Eastern Cape Province. [5.4 mb]
26 February 2021	Application for environmental authorisation in terms of the National Environmental Management Act, Act No. 107 Of 1998, as amended: The establishment of sea-based aquaculture development zone (ADZ) in Algoa Bay, within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality, Eastern Cape Province. [6.36 mb]